Physicists at the University of Bonn and the University of Kaiserslautern-Landau (RPTU) have created a one-dimensional gas out of light. This has enabled them to test theoretical predictions about the transition into this exotic state of matter for the first time. The method used in the experiment by the researchers could be used for examining quantum effects. The results have been published in Nature Physics.
Imagine you are standing at a swimming pool and come up with the idea of filling it with even more water. You grab a garden hose and use it to generate a jet of water that curves in a high arc to fall onto the surface of the pool. The water level increases briefly at the point where the jet of water hits the pool, but this change in water level is only minimal because the falling water is quickly distributed across the entire expanse of water.
The effect is different, however, if you fill up a gutter with your jet of water. The jet creates a wave of water at the point where you aim the hose. This is because the walls of the gutter ensure that the water cannot flow out across a surface but can only be distributed in the direction of the gutter. The narrower the gutter, the higher the amplitude of the wave and thus the “more one-dimensional” it becomes.
Physicists from the Institute of Applied Physics (IAP) at the University of Bonn, in cooperation with colleagues at the RPTU, have now investigated whether similar effects of dimensionality can also be achieved with gases made out of light particles.
“To create these types of gases, we need to concentrate lots of photons in a confined space and cool them simultaneously,” explains Dr. Frank Vewinger from the IAP, who is also a member of the transdisciplinary research area “Matter” at the University of Bonn.
Microscopically small gutters
In their experiment, the researchers filled a tiny container with a dye solution and excited it using a laser. The resulting photons bounced back and forth between the reflective walls of the container. Whenever they collided with a dye molecule, they were cooled until ultimately the photon gas condensed.
The dimensionality of the gas can be influenced by modifying the surface of the reflective surfaces. The researchers at the IAP cooperated with the research group headed by Prof. Dr. Georg von Freymann from the RPTU on this study. A high-resolution structuring method was adapted so that it could be applied to the reflective surfaces of the photon container for this experiment.
“We were able to apply a transparent polymer to the reflective surfaces to create microscopically small protrusions,” explains Julian Schulz from the RPTU. “These protrusions allow us to trap the photons in one or two dimensions and condense them.”
“These polymers act like a type of gutter, but in this case for light,” says Kirankumar Karkihalli Umesh, lead author of the study. “The narrower this gutter is, the more one-dimensionally the gas behaves.”
Thermal fluctuations smear out the condensation point
In two dimensions, there is a precise temperature limit at which condensation occurs—similar to how water freezes at precisely zero degrees Celsius. Physicists call this a phase transition. “However, things are a little different when we create a one-dimensional gas instead of a two-dimensional one,” says Vewinger.
“So-called thermal fluctuations take place in photon gases but they are so small in two dimensions that they have no real impact. However, in one dimension, these fluctuations can—figuratively speaking—make big waves.”
These fluctuations destroy the order of one-dimensional systems so that different regions within the gas no longer behave the same. As a result, the phase transition, which is still precisely defined in two dimensions, becomes increasingly “smeared out” the more one-dimensional the system becomes.
However, its properties are still governed by quantum physics, as in the case of two-dimensional gases, and these types of gas are called degenerate quantum gases. It is as if water were to turn into a form of icy water at low temperatures without ever completely freezing when cooling down.
“We have now been able to investigate this behavior at the transition from a two-dimensional to a one-dimensional photon gas for the first time,” explains Vewinger.
The research groups were able to demonstrate that one-dimensional photon gases do not actually have a precise condensation point. By making tiny changes to the polymer structures, it will now be possible to investigate phenomena that occur at the transition between different dimensionalities in great detail.
This is still considered basic research at the moment but it is possible that it could open up new areas of application for quantum optical effects.
Reference: Kirankumar Karkihalli Umesh et al, Dimensional crossover in a quantum gas of light, Nature Physics (2024). DOI: 10.1038/s41567-024-02641-7
